Why Trade Wars are Class Wars

---

• Global markets are deeply influenced by factors beyond traditional economic indicators, including internal political and social dynamics within countries.
• Effective investment strategies require a comprehensive understanding of these internal dynamics, rather than solely focusing on international relations or trade balances.
• A long-term, data-driven approach, coupled with a willingness to challenge conventional wisdom, is essential for successful investing.

When we discuss the global economy, it’s tempting to fall into simplistic narratives. We see headlines about trade wars and immediately think, "disaster." We hear about Germany's trade surplus and assume it's all about efficient production and thrifty consumers.

But as economist and author Matt Klein points out, this kind of zero-sum thinking often misses the mark. “The whole point of our book Trade Wars are Class Wars,” Matt explains, “is that there are lots of positive-sum solutions and that the idea of like a zero-sum framing is completely wrong and that everyone can be better off if we do certain things differently.”

Matt is the author of Overshoot, a Substack that tracks the global economy, and co-author of Trade Wars are Class Wars. He’s spent decades analyzing market dynamics, first at Bridgewater and then as a writer for publications like The Economist, Bloomberg, and the Financial Times. He also served as a research assistant to Sebastian Mallaby on his biography of Alan Greenspan.

Matt delves into the complexities of global macroeconomic trends, challenging conventional wisdom and offering a nuanced perspective crucial for investors. He argues that focusing on internal dynamics within countries, rather than just inter-country relationships, is essential for understanding the global economic picture.

From the true story behind Germany's economic performance to the complexities of the bond market and the potential pitfalls of simplistic policy solutions, Matt’s insights provide a crucial framework for investors.

Decoding global economic trends

Matt’s analysis provides investors with a nuanced understanding of the forces shaping the global economy, going beyond simplistic narratives often presented in the media. He emphasizes the interconnected nature of global markets, demonstrating how seemingly isolated events can ripple across borders and impact seemingly unrelated asset classes. For example, he explains how "all economies and all people are linked together globally through trade and finance…[creating] consequences for people in the rest of the world." This intricate web of relationships means that investors can no longer afford to view markets in isolation. A slowdown in one region can trigger a cascade of effects, impacting demand, supply chains, and investor sentiment across the globe.

One of Matt’s key insights is the importance of looking beyond international relations and delving into the internal dynamics of individual nations. He argues that understanding the interplay of political, social, and economic forces within a country can be more informative than simply focusing on its interactions with other nations. He highlights China as a prime example, explaining how "things are happening in China for their own domestic internal reasons…[and these have] consequences for people in the rest of the world." This perspective challenges investors to develop a more granular understanding of the factors driving economic change, looking beyond macroeconomic indicators and considering the nuances of domestic policy, consumer behavior, and internal political dynamics.

Matt encourages a shift away from a purely Western-centric view, recognizing the increasing influence of emerging economies and the interconnectedness of global markets. By understanding the specific drivers of these economies and their potential impact on global trends, investors can identify both risks and opportunities that a more traditional approach might overlook. This deeper understanding allows for more strategic asset allocation, more effective risk management, and ultimately, the potential for greater returns in a global market.

Unveiling market opportunities and risks

Matt's insights offer valuable guidance for investors seeking to identify both opportunities and risks in the current market environment. He highlights the potential pitfalls of simplistic thinking, particularly in the context of trade wars and protectionist policies. Matt explains that tariffs, often touted as a solution to domestic economic woes, can have unintended consequences: "Imposing tariffs or threatening to impose tariffs tends to make the dollar go up." This strengthening of the dollar can negatively impact US-based investments, making them less attractive to foreign investors and potentially reducing returns. Investors should therefore carefully consider the ripple effects of trade policies on currency valuations and global capital flows.

Beyond trade, Matt discusses the importance of understanding market dynamics and avoiding overreliance on traditional metrics. He points out that common indicators, like the term premium in bond markets, can be misleading if not interpreted correctly. He explains how "any volatility in 10-year rates looks like it's a term premium" even when other factors are at play. He cautions investors against making hasty decisions based on surface-level market fluctuations. Instead, a deeper understanding of the underlying economic forces and a data-driven approach to analysis are essential for identifying true opportunities and avoiding potential traps.

Despite the complexities and potential risks, Matt’s analysis also reveals significant opportunities for discerning investors. He notes that periods of economic uncertainty, such as the one following German reunification, can create fertile ground for innovation and growth. As he explains, "[the post-reunification period]…motivated [Germany] to understand [the economy] better…so that we can…manage these systems better and have better outcomes for everyone.”

Similarly, investors who can identify companies and sectors adapting and innovating in response to economic challenges are likely to find promising long-term investment opportunities. This requires looking beyond short-term market fluctuations and understanding the long-term drivers of growth and value creation. By combining a nuanced understanding of global trends with careful analysis of individual companies and sectors, investors can position themselves to capitalize on the opportunities arising from economic change.

Challenging conventional investment wisdom

Matt challenges several commonly held beliefs in the investment world, encouraging investors to question assumptions and think critically about prevailing market narratives. He critiques the tendency to focus solely on international trade balances, arguing that a deeper understanding of internal dynamics is essential. As he explains, "It's not trade per se that's the problem. Trade is the mechanism that transmits these other problems from one place to another place."

He also questions the conventional wisdom surrounding Germany's economic success, often attributed to its export-oriented model. Matt argues that this narrative overlooks the negative consequences of Germany's internal policies, such as suppressed wage growth and reduced social spending. He notes that these policies while contributing to a trade surplus, have also led to stagnant living standards for many Germans and created imbalances in the global economy. He challenges the notion that export strength alone is a reliable indicator of economic health and encourages investors to consider a broader range of factors when evaluating investment opportunities.

Furthermore, Matt questions the simplistic view that surpluses and deficits are inherently good or bad. He argues that the context and underlying causes of these imbalances are crucial. "There are a lot of different possibilities depending upon…what point in time you are, where you are. And they're not all bad." By understanding these complexities, investors can avoid misinterpreting economic data and make more informed investment decisions. He encourages investors to challenge prevailing narratives, conduct thorough due diligence, and develop independent perspectives on market dynamics.

The long view: Preparing for the future

Matt emphasizes the importance of a long-term perspective in investing, particularly in the face of short-term market volatility and economic uncertainty. He cautions against overreacting to daily headlines and encourages investors to focus on underlying trends. Reflecting on past predictions, he notes, "I mean, I will say that at the time last summer, I was saying that we shouldn't overreact…and it is gratifying to see that that actually seems to be what happened."

For long-term investors, understanding the potential trajectory of the global economy is paramount. While acknowledging the inherent difficulty of prediction, Matt highlights the need for adaptability and scenario planning. He suggests that investors should prepare for a range of potential outcomes, from continued growth to economic slowdowns or potential "policy disruptions." This forward-thinking approach involves considering how different macroeconomic scenarios might impact various asset classes and adjusting portfolios accordingly. Diversification across geographies, sectors, and asset types becomes even more critical in this context, mitigating the risks associated with any single economic outcome.

Matt also stresses the importance of understanding the interplay between monetary policy, fiscal policy, and market behavior. By analyzing the actions of central banks, government spending patterns, and investor sentiment, long-term investors can gain a deeper understanding of the forces shaping the future of the global economy. This includes recognizing the limitations of relying solely on traditional economic models and incorporating a broader range of factors into their analysis. By adopting a holistic and forward-looking perspective, investors can better position themselves to navigate the long-term challenges and capitalize on the opportunities that lie ahead.

A global mindset for a global market

Matt’s insights provide a crucial framework that challenges conventional wisdom, urging investors to look beyond simplistic narratives and delve into the internal dynamics driving global economic shifts. By embracing a truly global perspective, challenging assumptions, and focusing on data-driven decision-making, investors can better position themselves to manage risk and capitalize on opportunities.

The future of investing is global, and success belongs to those who embrace the complexity.

---

This is based on an episode of Top Traders Unplugged, a bi-weekly podcast with the most interesting and experienced investors, economists, traders and thought leaders in the world. Sign up to our Newsletter or Subscribe on your preferred podcast platform so that you don’t miss out on future episodes.