Before the Next “Healthy Correction,” Ask These 5 Questions

---

Modern Market Selloff Drivers: Why Crowding and Leverage Matter More Than Headlines

Investors love catalysts, maybe because a catalyst is neat. It gives the market a plot and turns chaos into a headline. It also helps you tell yourself that the world still runs on understandable causes and effects.

But markets do not always fall because something new happened. Sometimes markets fall because too many people were positioned for the same world, and that world stopped behaving. That distinction matters, because it changes what you watch the next time prices get “gnarly” and everyone starts speaking in standard deviations.

In a modern selloff, the storyline tends to arrive late. The mechanics arrive first.

The Market’s Most Important Question Is Not "What Happened?”

The more useful question is: what was crowded, and how was it funded? Crowding is a strange word. It sounds like popularity, but it’s more specific than that. A crowded trade is one that many portfolios depend on for the same purpose, and it becomes a shared answer to a shared fear.

In recent years, one cluster became a convenient answer to many questions. Secular growth and mega-cap technology offered liquidity and perceived quality. AI enthusiasm offered a narrative of inevitability, software felt borderless, and crypto offered upside and a story that could be repeated in one sentence.

Then there were the macro add-ons, such as a weak dollar narrative, a belief that real assets, like gold and silver, were a direct expression of debasement concerns, as well as a sense that international and cyclical trades would thrive as the world rebalanced.

None of those ideas are inherently wrong. The danger is when they become the same bet expressed across different tickers. You can diversify holdings and still concentrate outcomes.

Why Low Volatility Can Be a Warning Sign

Most investors treat low volatility as a sign of safety. Professionals treat it as something else: capacity.

Many strategies scale exposure based on volatility. Volatility targeting funds, risk parity portfolios, and a wide family of systematic strategies use leverage to reach a target risk level. If volatility is low, they can hold more. If volatility rises, they must hold less. This is rational, and it is also destabilizing.

When volatility is low, leverage can build quietly. It feels responsible, because it is “risk adjusted.” It feels measured, because it is based on a formula rather than emotion. It feels safe, because nothing is shaking, but the system has a hinge.

If volatility rises, the same strategies reduce exposure at the same time. If trend signals stall or reverse, they reduce exposure again. When the gross exposure in the system is high, the unwind can be violent. This is one reason modern drawdowns can feel impersonal. The selling is not a panic; it is a rule book.

The Spark Is Usually Small, Because the Pile Is Big

People want the one cause, but the market is usually a bundle of causes.

Maybe it’s a shift in the dollar, or a surprise in data, a change in expected central bank policy, or a political development that changes the temperature of risk. Any of these can become a spark. But sparks only become fires when there is fuel, and the fuel is positioning.

When many investors are short the dollar, or long the same growth complex, or long the same metals trade, it does not take much for profit taking to turn into de-risking. As people reduce exposure, prices move. As prices move, models respond. As models respond, selling becomes broader.

This is how a market narrative can go from “healthy correction” to “we might need to rerecord the intro.”

Why Bitcoin Can Trade Like Technology

One of the most revealing parts of modern market stress is watching what moves together.

Bitcoin is typically described as a monetary alternative. Gold is described as a debasement hedge. Software is described as a business model, not a macro asset. In a calm market, those labels can hold. In a stressed market, liquidity can erase them all.

If the same cohorts own the same assets, then their financial constraints connect those assets. A tech ecosystem that is heavily compensated in equity and restricted stock can face a very specific kind of pressure when software falls. If you cannot sell your restricted shares, you sell what you can. If you want liquidity, you sell the liquid things you own.

That is why bitcoin can trade like a high-beta technology proxy when stress hits the digital ecosystem, not because the philosophical story changed, but because the ownership overlap matters. This can be uncomfortable, because it suggests that “uncorrelated” sometimes means “uncorrelated until the moment you need it.”

The Buyback Bid, and What Happens When it Weakens

Another feature of recent markets is the steady presence of corporate repurchases. Buybacks are not merely demand. They are a stabilizer. When markets fall, buybacks can become more active, providing a bid that dampens volatility. It’s not heroic. It’s structural. But buybacks depend on cash.

If cash is redirected into large capital spending programs, including AI related investments, companies can have less flexibility to support repurchases. If they fund spending through debt issuance, credit markets can absorb more supply. If spreads were already tight, the market may demand more compensation.

This does not require a credit crisis. It only requires the market to move from “there is always a buyer” to “the buyer is not as steady.” A small shift in the shock absorber can change the ride.

Why Correlation Can Rise in a Strange Way

In a classic crash, correlation rises because fear rises. Everything moves together. Modern markets can behave differently, especially when market neutral and multi strategy funds play a larger role.

These funds often hold longs and shorts. When they de-risk, they can sell longs and cover shorts at the same time. That creates a market where many stocks are up while many are down, even on large index moves. You can see violent movement without the clean “risk off” pattern investors expect.

It can feel like the world is breaking, while the volatility signals look oddly sticky. That’s the market telling you something important: the plumbing is in charge.

What Stops the Bleed

The end of these episodes is rarely a heroic act. It’s usually a process.

Exposure comes down, hedges get monetized, dealers adjust, volatility sellers return when the coast feels clearer, and dip buyers reappear, sometimes through short-dated options. Systematic strategies reduce pressure as volatility stabilizes, selling slows, then the market can bounce, sometimes sharply.

These reversals can feel confusing because they look like sentiment changed overnight. They’re the mechanical unwind and re-risk cycle of the same flow-driven system.

The Investing Lesson

Howard Marks has spent decades reminding investors that risk is not a number. It is what happens when you are wrong. Other elite thinkers in the space have spent years showing that behavior and incentives explain more than spreadsheets do. Both ideas point to the same practical takeaway here: Pay attention to fragility, as you do not need to forecast the next headline. You need to notice when the market is set up to overreact.

Here are a few questions that help:

1. How crowded are the trades that have been working?
2. How much leverage is embedded in strategies that must reduce exposure when volatility rises?
3. Are the “diversifiers” truly different, or just different wrappers on the same risk?
4. Is a structural bid, like buybacks, strengthening or fading?
5. Are credit spreads tight while supply is rising?

The goal is not to be pessimistic but to recognize that modern markets are shaped by flows and constraints as much as they are shaped by fundamentals. Most investors think a selloff is a story. Usually, though, it’s a plumbing problem.

And if you want to survive the next one, you don’t just need conviction. You need an understanding of what forces people to sell, even when they would prefer not to.

---

Be sure to listen to Top Traders Unplugged, a biweekly podcast with the most intriguing and experienced investors, economists, traders, and thought leaders in the world. Sign up for our Newsletter and subscribe on your preferred podcast platform so that you don't miss out on future episodes.